Breaking Boundaries: Inside the Controversial Laugh-Fest in Saudi Arabia
"Audiences heard risqué humor, and LGBTQ+ material. This is unprecedented to experience this kind of comedy within the Kingdom."
That's how an international attendee characterized the performances she's seen at the pioneering Riyadh Comedy Festival.
"The reception was phenomenal," she noted, after sets by US comedians Bill Burr and Dave Chappelle.
Comedy Limits
The festival-goer - referred to as Sara - stated the performers steered clear of discussing the Kingdom's debated rights issues.
"Residents show little interest about such subjects," she explained. "Otherwise, they'd reside elsewhere."
Internationally, opinions diverge significantly.
Famous comedians featuring Jack Whitehall, Kevin Hart, Jimmy Carr faced strong backlash from other comedians for agreeing to perform at the event.
Audience Reactions
One of the first fans to enter was Zain, not his real name.
He saw performances by Djalili and Burr with acquaintances, and is booked in to see the British comic later.
"The first comic for Bill Burr contained a ten-minute segment which was centered around risqué material."
Zain, who resides in the capital, said he was shocked to experience such comedy in a nation which is known for being ultra-conservative socially.
"It's remarkable comedians were delivering such material in the Kingdom," he commented. "Many people here are unfamiliar with a stand-up in their lives, much less something this bold."
Show Content
However, the humor got positive reactions, he said. "Among the audience, [there was a group] of local Saudi women, and everyone was chuckling."
The American star's show was equally contentious, as reported by the attendee, with numerous routines about trans people.
She said such content is "rare" to hear jokes like that in the Middle Eastern country.
According to spectators that Djalili poked fun at elements of Saudi culture.
"He comically mentioned the niqab, and ladies behind the wheel. He also presented a segment about how people in Riyadh think."
Performance Limitations
Then there's the avoided subjects.
Spectators consulted said the performances "entirely dodged" any mention of the government in Saudi Arabia.
Ahead of the festival, advocacy groups claimed the festival was an attempt by the Saudi regime to "whitewash" its abuses.
An entertainer, who refused an offer to appear, published sections of a contract that supposedly featured restrictions regarding any routines that could "disparage or slander the Saudi royal family or religious institutions.
English entertainer noted it's extremely rare for comedians to receive similar material limitations.
"I've only heard occasionally at performances at universities," she mentioned. "However, these are rare not typical procedure."
Moral Questions
The event's scheduling has been noted by its critics.
When it's happening, from the end of September, align with the seven-year mark of the death of writer Jamal Khashoggi.
"The identical individual who is paying [the comedians] is that very person who funded that guy to kill the journalist," remarked entertainer Marc Maron.
"According to traditional wisdom, that laughter confronts leadership," she noted. "Numerous entertainers have been huge defenders of free speech, and to appear in Saudi Arabia, where expression faces limitations, is extraordinary. It's morally repugnant."
Payment Issues
Several entertainers have openly stated about what's drawn them to this opportunity - financial compensation.
"The compensation enough money to ignore issues," entertainer Tim Dillon mentioned during an interview.
Dillon, who reports being removed from the event after those comments, also claimed he had been presented with significant payment for his performance.
Performer Shane Gillis said on his podcast he had turned down substantial compensation to participate in the showcase. "I took a principled stand," he said.
"No one goes into comedy for the paycheque," says Holt.
"The individuals specifically receiving offers are people who already very successful," commented another comedian. "The current period isn't a challenging period for successful performers."
Social Evolution
Entertainers aren't the only ones who have accepted substantial compensation from the Kingdom's authorities in recent times.
Being a country that has been reliant on petroleum, the Kingdom is working to diversify itself across various fields.
The Kingdom's modernization program, led by Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman, involves investing resources into {sectors such as|areas including|fields